The question seems to come down to whether Jimmy deserves a permanent ban for his immature behavior. Please keep in mind that Jimmy is 21 years old and is still capable of learning from his mistakes. He claims that he has learned his lesson and will not repeat the negative behaviors that he displayed previously. I don't believe that giving Jimmy the opportunity to prove himself will adversely affect our DG community. There will be plenty of people watching his every move and reporting things to staff and admins. I know I wouldn't want to live in that type of environment, but he is asking for this chance. Jimmy and I aren't even close friends, however I feel the need to advocate for him. Jimmy has apologized and knows what is at stake. Reduce the ban to something reasonable.